Which Is Sounder in Sharia: the Stricter Opinion or the Lenient One?
Answered by Shaykh Faraz Rabbani
Question
I recently read a quote explaining why someone takes the hardliner approach: “If we, as the leaders and scholars, take the path of concessions (lenient opinions), the laymen will take an even softer approach and the entire religion will be buried.”
On the other hand, there are ulema who prefer to adopt the lenient opinion, because Islam was not sent to mankind to make their lives difficult.
In Shariah, usul al-fiqh and aqida, which one has the sounder basis, is the better approach, and will net better results?
Answer
In the Name of Allah, the Merciful and Compassionate.
Neither hardness nor leniency is the measure of what is right for individuals, communities, societies, and the Umma. The measure is the balance that Allah Most High sent His Beloved Messenger (Allah bless him and give him peace) with.
The straight path of Islam is one of beautiful, perfect balance: the relied-upon positions of qualified scholarship, free of excessiveness and of negligence, conveyed with mercy and wisdom. This is the Prophetic inheritance, and its custodians are the mindful, wise scholars (al-ulama al-rabbaniyyin).
Islam Is the Middle Way Between Excess and Neglect
The notion of “balance” is so important that Imam Abu Jaʿfar al-Tahawi (Allah have mercy on him), in his statement of Sunni creed, makes it a point of belief (aqida). He says, regarding Allah’s religion, “It is between excess and falling short; between likening Allah to creation and stripping Him of His attributes; between compulsion and free will; and between feeling safe from Allah and despairing of Him.” [Tahawi, al-ʿAqida al-Tahawiyya] Meaning: it is the perfect balance of these (and other) matters, without falling into excess or remissness.
«وهو بين الغلو والتقصير، وبين التشبيه والتعطيل، وبين الجبر والقدر، وبين الأمن والإياس»
Shaykh Shujaʿ al-Din al-Turkistani (Allah have mercy on him), a Hanafi and Maturidi commentator, explains that “leaning toward either side is a departure from uprightness (istiqama).” Excessiveness, he explains, is to go beyond the right limit set for a thing, and falling short stops below it, and each, he says, is blameworthy and false, because it leaves the justice and truth Allah has given to Divine Guidance. [Turkistani, Sharh al-ʿAqida al-Tahawiyya]
Shaykh Abd al-Ghani al-Maydani (Allah have mercy on him), in his commentary on Tahawi’s creed, cites al-Hasan al-Basri: “Allah’s religion was set below excess and above falling short.” [Maydani, Sharh al-ʿAqida al-Tahawiyya]
Allah Most High says, “And so too have We made you a select nation of faith, nobly upright in equity, that you might be witnesses over all men.” [Quran 2:143; Keller, The Quran Beheld]
How This Is Manifest in the Legal Rulings of Islam
In law, the balance is the relied-upon position your school relies on. This is found not just in books, but through the careful consideration of living, trained, godfearing (muttaqi) scholars.
The great Hanafi jurist of the 11th Century, Imam Alaʾ al-Din al-Haskafi (Allah have mercy on him), states that whoever is unaware of their times is not a scholar. [Haskafi, al-Durr al-Mukhtar] This is because applying the Law requires an understanding of context, implications, and those addressed. One doesn’t just pick the harder view or the easier one; one follows the stronger one, all relevant matters considered.
Strictness Is Not the Same as Taqwa
Imam Birkawi (Allah have mercy on him), known in Turkish as Birgivi, closes al-Tariqa al-Muhammadiyya with a chapter on things people take for godfearingness (taqwa) and scrupulousness that are “not of them in anything.” They are “counted among baseless misgivings and cold scrupulousness,” and the early Muslims, he says, “were upon breadth and dispensation, and gave fatwa to people by them.” [Birkawi, al-Tariqa al-Muhammadiyya]
This is an understanding of the Prophet’s call to “make things easy for people, and do not make them difficult.” But “making easy” is to facilitate for people to pursue the true good of this life and the true good of the next, given where they are at.
Sidi Abd al-Ghani al-Nablusi (Allah have mercy on him) adds that such practices excessive strictness in giving fatwa arises from minds darkened by an “ignorance of the purposes of the Sacred Law.” [Nablusi, al-Hadiqa al-Nadiyya Sharh al-Tariqa al-Muhammadiyya]
The Messenger of Allah (Allah bless him and give him peace) said, “Make things easy and do not make them hard; give glad tidings and do not drive people away.” [Bukhari and Muslim]
True understanding, the scholars explained, inculcates mindfulness of Allah (taqwa), calls people to religiosity and uprightness, but with gentleness, wisdom, and by making the straight path “easy” in their lives.
Do Not Become a Cause of Fitna
Imam Birkawi emphasizes that preachers and muftis must know people’s states and habits, “so they speak with what is most beneficial and fitting for them, so that their speech does not become a trial (fitna) for people.” [Birkawi, al-Tariqa al-Muhammadiyya] The “fitna” is for them to find religion “difficult” and thereby turn away.
His example is the one who tells villagers that prayer without perfect recitation is invalid, so they leave prayer altogether.
In his commentary on Imam Birkawi’s work, Imam Abu Saʿid al-Khadimi (Allah have mercy on him) says of a view that is weak in transmission yet strong in reasoning, and that people act upon, that holding to it is more befitting, to avoid confusion and fitna. [Khadimi, Bariqa Mahmudiyya]
Sidi Abd al-Ghani al-Nablusi laments some “preachers” of his time: “You see them spreading fitna among people with the strictness in religion they impose in minor matters, while they keep silent about enormous sins.” [Nablusi, al-Hadiqa al-Nadiyya]
Undue strictness on small matters drives people from the religion.
Sidi Abd al-Ghani’s words also highlight the need to take religion from the people of true knowledge, wisdom, and balance—and the danger of taking one’s deen from “preachers” without these characteristics.
Our Age Calls for Encouragement and the Shepherd’s Care
Ours is an age for encouraging people, as our teachers have long counseled, not for sternness that makes them turn away.
Yet guiding people means being like the shepherd. The Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) said, “Each of you is a shepherd, and each of you is responsible for his flock.” [Bukhari and Muslim]
A shepherd wants to bring his flock toward the good. But he knows that this takes encouragement, and at times firmness.
But the general ethos of the Sunna is mercy, gentleness, calm, and wisdom.
So take your religion from reliable scholars who have these characteristics, both in their teachings and in their own upright practice and character, and carry it to others as Allah Most High commands: “Call to the path of your Lord with wisdom and goodly admonishment.” [Quran 16:125; Keller, The Quran Beheld]
And Allah knows best.
Faraz Rabbani
Related Answers
One. Are Minority Opinions Sinful to Follow in Islam? — Shaykh Faraz Rabbani: Following any sound position of qualified, mainstream scholars fulfills the command to ask those who know.
Two. What Are the Limits of Taking Easier Opinions Across Madhabs? — Shaykh Faraz Rabbani: Moving between valid positions is allowed; chasing dispensations by whim is not.
Three. The Path of Taqwa: Avoiding Differences of Opinion — Shaykh Faraz Rabbani: The place of precaution, and its conditions.
Four. Is Opting for the Easiest Fatwa Among Differing Scholarly Opinions Sinful? — Shaykh Irshaad Sedick: Ease isn’t sinful in itself, yet it is no license to shop for fatwas.
النصوص · Source-Texts
[الطحاوي، العقيدة الطحاوية] «ودين الله في الأرض والسماء واحد، وهو دين الإسلام … وهو بين الغلو والتقصير، وبين التشبيه والتعطيل، وبين الجبر والقدر، وبين الأمن والإياس»
[التركستاني، شرح العقيدة الطحاوية] «وإنما قال ذلك لأن الميل إلى أحد الطرفين خروج عن الاستقامة، والغلو هو المجاوزة عن الحد المجعول له، والتقصير نزول عن الحد المجعول له، وكل واحد منهما مذموم وباطل لخروجه عن العدل والحق»
[الميداني، شرح العقيدة الطحاوية] «وهو أي دين الإسلام الحنيفي متوسط بين الغلو تجاوز الحدود والتقصير عنها … عن الحسن قال: إن دين الله تعالى وضع دون الغلو وفوق التقصير»
[الحصكفي، الدر المختار] «وأن الحكم والفتيا بالقول المرجوح جهل وخرق للإجماع»
[البركوي، الطريقة المحمدية] «في أمور يظن أنها من التقوى والورع بسبب نوع مناسبة ومشابهة لها وإكباب بعض الزهاد في زماننا عليها وليست منهما في شيء بل هي بدع حدثت بعد الصدر الأول، ومعدودة من الوسوسة والورع البارد … وأنهم كانوا على سعة ورخصة وفتوى بهما فيه»
[النابلسي، الحديقة الندية] «حدثت باستحسان العقول المظلمة بظلمة النفس الجاهلة بالمقاصد الشرعية»
[البركوي، الطريقة المحمدية] «فعلى الوعاظ والمفتين معرفة أحوال الناس وعادتهم في القبول والرد والسعي والكسل ونحوها فيتكلمون بالأصلح والأوفق لهم حتى لا يكون كلامهم فتنة للناس»
[الخادمي، بريقة محمودية] «وهذه الرواية وإن كانت ضعيفة رواية قوية دراية فالقول بها ألزم فرارا من الفتنة»
[النابلسي، الحديقة الندية] «وما أجهل غالب وعاظ زماننا لهذه المباحث فتراهم يكثرون الفتن بين الناس بما يلقونه إليهم من التشديد في الدين في الأمور السهلة الجزئية، ويسكتون عن عظائم الذنوب»